The Women's Surprise Box

Taylor Tillman

Everything looked wonderful on me and fit me beautifully with the exception of one shirt that was just way way way too small

The good experience encouraged me to try your calypso Saint Bart package

I like these mystery boxes. I have never owned a pair of Nisolo shoes I didn't like. I will definitely buy a mystery box again if offered.

If I could give this 0 stars I would. I ordered the $200 box, which was supposed to contain $1000 worth of merchandise. I received 2 items - poorly made, flimsy, and not even worth $50 apiece in my opinion. I requested to send the items back for a refund and was told my request would need “manual review.” I’m still waiting on a response but wanted to warn anyone considering the item. Save your money and time.

They did not do anything wrong, but the styles that showed in the picture were very different to what I got in the box. I got 2 dresses. They were not like any of the casual airy style shown as examples, one was a formal long dress and the other a very niche mini dress that did not even fit despite being a medium. I am in my 60’s so not at all to my style. My reccomendation to them if they want to delight is to take age into consideration and not deviate from the styles shown in the sample so radically. I asked for a swap of lower value even but they did not. Having said that it was final sale! End result is I am dussapointed and won’t try again next time.

I can’t imagine single person who would have enjoyed or looked good in the items I was sent. Weird cut outs for all the items in unflattering places. Very nonstandard sizing. I am a classic 12/14 XL. Somehow these pieces had too long arms, too short skirts, weirdly long/short torsos. Every single item is going to Goodwill. Lesson learned. Don’t bother with these “mystery boxes”!

I was happy with my 3 surprise pairs from Nisolo. I received sandals, low heels and booties, all in neutral colors. Shipping was fast.

Lovely shoes. I'll probably give the healed boots to friend, but the other two pairs of shoes where lovely. Even my 2 year old mentioned he like my new shoes

This was my second box. My first boc had 5 items. This box had three. Two of which is a set. I love them. Excellent quality.

I got a really cute pair of sandals like the ones pictured, an adorable pair of derby shoes and a gorgeous of boots. I would absolutely purchase another box if I knew I would get different shoes!! Such a great deal on beautiful, quality, footwear!!

The Surprise Box - Nisolo Edition - FINAL SALE

Do not order! They sent odd sizes and refused to help.

Beautiful shoes but mostly boots and I live by the beach. Should have thought it through. I got men’s and women’s shoes btw

I was thrilled with this mystery box. The items are all well made. I cannot tell what the “imperfections” are. I got beautiful sandals, pumps and booties. They are all neutral shades of tan/beige and are all appropriate for dressing up or down. I was nervous about this purchase but I’m so pleased!!!

Liked what I got but one model was one that they recommend sizing down for, so since I ordered true to size, did not fit.

My suggestion before purchase would be to check the brand website for sample sale products. My entire box was Emerson Fry was from the same "India" collection. Although I personally like the clothes, if you are expecting clothing on par with typical items from the brand this is NOT that. The price is still better than the sample sale prices but this is all sample sale items from either an unlaunched line or a failed line, it isn't just past season- it's sample meaning the brand on the box is no indicator of the style of clothing you will be receiving. It is 100% a mystery box whether you know the designer or not.

I was ok, nice shoes, packaging was messy.
Shoe selection not bad, but not what i was hoping for

I took a chance and ordered this surprise box. I received a great selection of shoes and they all fit perfectly! I'm very pleased with everything I received!

I will not try again

Sizes and fit were all over the place. I received multiple of the same items from the last box i purchased.

Wow. For $200 i got 3 items, msrv definitely totaling $1000. One was a green lace crop top. One was a beautifully hand beaded shift with armholes to my waist that firs like a potato sack; and one was a 10-pound gathered & tiered maxi skirt that looks like it’s made from a comforter, thick & quilted. Final sale. I mean, i took a chance on odd clothes but too odd for my taste!

I was really pleased with the items I received! It was way more than I expected, and the quality was top-notch. Everything fit me really well and each item had cool and unexpected details. I will be ordering again. I love a surprise!

What a great purchase! So much beauty and comfort, not to mention new looks and fabrics. Everything fit perfectly. The quality in each piece was inspiring. Your story and mission are admirable and I’m happy to wear these clothes knowing they have a home after their time with me.

Absolutely LOVE the clothes I received. This designer is one I would never have seen much less purchased before. I feel like a new person. At 75 I thought I had my style down pat. I’m definitely rethinking that without having to leave home.

Every piece was perfect and nothing I would have purchased for myself. Thank you for introducing me to a new me.

Very awkward fits, even for Emerson fry. Various sizes came.

The Women's Surprise Box - Something Navy Edition - FINAL SALE

The items are lovely. Didn't like every fabric equally but overall nice selection.

Great items

Worst selection of items. It’s the things that no one want. It’s mostly Beis collab/hoodies if you’re going to order.

Out of all items, there are maybe one or two that I may wear, and that is doubtful. Sizing between items was wildly inconsistent and quality seems quite low compared to other items I had bought from the brand